Beyond AC: How to Initiate the DC Discussion in Building Design
Key Steps for Architects and Owners to Spark the AC/DC Debate and Drive Innovation
By Robert Kroon
The paradigm of Alternating Current (AC) as the default power distribution system in buildings is being challenged. Advancements in renewable energy, battery storage, and a growing prevalence of Direct Current (DC) powered devices are highlighting the potential for increased efficiency, resilience, and sustainability in DC-powered buildings. However, initiating a serious evaluation of DC alongside traditional AC often requires a deliberate and strategic approach. As a building owner or architect, how can you effectively prompt a thorough exploration of both options for your next project? Here are key tactics to consider, moving beyond the conventional:
1. Leverage the Power of Competition with a Strategic RFP:
Start Here
August Berres can provide a template for your RFP needs. Please complete the form at the end of this article to receive it.
A well-crafted Request for Proposal (RFP) can be your most powerful tool in fostering a comparative analysis. Instead of implicitly leaning towards AC, design your RFP to actively encourage innovative thinking around power distribution:
Clearly Articulate Holistic Project Goals: Go beyond basic functional requirements. Detail your sustainability targets, energy efficiency aspirations, long-term operational needs, and any vision for integrating future technologies. This comprehensive overview sets the stage for considering diverse solutions.
Explicitly Solicit Alternative Solutions: Include specific language in the RFP inviting proposals for both AC and DC power distribution systems (where relevant to the firm's expertise). Request a clear justification for their recommended approach, backed by thorough analysis and a long-term perspective.
Define Comprehensive and Weighted Evaluation Criteria: Move beyond simply comparing upfront costs. Your evaluation rubric should prioritize factors such as life-cycle cost, energy efficiency, system resilience, scalability, environmental impact, and the potential for seamless integration of renewable energy sources and future technologies.
Facilitate Deeper Understanding Through Pre-Bid Engagement: Organize comprehensive pre-bid meetings to allow potential bidders to ask detailed questions and gain a nuanced understanding of your objectives. This fosters more informed and innovative proposals that directly address your specific needs and challenges.
2. Implement Checks and Balances by Separating Design and Construction
System design is a critical activity. Separate it from construction.
The traditional design-build model can sometimes lead to inertia favoring familiar AC systems. To ensure a more objective evaluation, consider unbundling the project phases:
Engage Independent Engineering Expertise for Design: Commission an engineering firm with demonstrable expertise in both AC and DC power systems to develop a comprehensive design based purely on technical merit and the building's specific requirements. This independent evaluation can provide an unbiased assessment of the optimal power distribution system, free from immediate construction cost pressures.
Foster Competitive Bidding for Construction: Once the design is finalized (regardless of whether it specifies AC, DC, or a hybrid approach), open the construction phase to competitive bidding from qualified contractors. This ensures that the construction firm focuses on efficient and accurate implementation of the chosen design, without the potential bias of having influenced the initial system selection.
This separation creates a vital system of checks and balances, ensuring that the choice of power distribution is driven by technical optimization rather than potential revenue advantages for a single entity. Strong communication and collaboration between the design and construction teams remain crucial for project success.
3. Cultivate Internal Knowledge and Proactive Dialogue
Empowering yourself and your team with knowledge is paramount in driving informed discussions:
Invest in Education: Dedicate time to understanding the fundamental principles, benefits, and limitations of both AC and DC power systems. Stay updated on industry trends, emerging technologies, and successful DC building implementations.
Conduct Early Stakeholder Workshops: Initiate conversations early in the project lifecycle. Organize workshops with engineers, contractors, sustainability consultants, and other key stakeholders to specifically explore innovative power distribution options, including the potential of DC for your project.
Seek Diverse Expertise: When selecting partners, actively look for firms with demonstrable experience or a strong interest in exploring alternative power systems. Their unique perspectives and specialized knowledge can significantly enrich the discussion and lead to more creative solutions.
4. Tailor the Discussion to Specific Building Needs and Goals
A DC building can be accomplished in a retrofit of an older space.
Frame the AC vs. DC conversation around the unique characteristics and objectives of your project:
Highlight DC-Advantageous Loads: If your building design incorporates a significant number of inherent DC loads (LED lighting, IT infrastructure, EV charging stations, security systems), explicitly emphasize the potential for efficiency gains by directly powering these devices with DC, minimizing energy-wasting AC-DC conversions.
Emphasize Renewable Energy Synergies: If integrating on-site renewable energy sources like solar photovoltaic arrays (which generate DC power) is a key project goal, highlight how a DC distribution system can streamline this integration and reduce energy losses associated with multiple conversions.
Address Resilience and Backup Power Strategies: Explore the inherent advantages of DC systems for integrating battery storage for backup power. DC-based backup solutions can often offer higher efficiency and more direct power delivery to critical DC loads during grid outages.
Consider Future-Proofing the Infrastructure: Prompt a discussion about how the building's power infrastructure can be designed to adapt to the increasing prevalence of DC-powered devices, smart building technologies, and evolving energy management systems.
5. Implement Pilot Programs and Phased Integration
Reduce initial risk and gather real-world data through strategic implementation:
Pilot DC Zones: For larger developments, consider implementing a DC microgrid or pilot program in a specific area of the building. This allows for monitoring performance, gathering data on energy savings, and building confidence before a full-scale commitment.
Phased DC Integration: Explore a phased approach where certain systems or areas of the building are initially powered by DC, with the potential for future expansion based on performance evaluation and evolving needs.
6. Demand Comparative and Data-Driven Analysis
Base your decisions on robust data and long-term perspectives:
August Berres power systems feature batteries engineered for long life.
Request Comprehensive Life-Cycle Cost Assessments: Insist on detailed life-cycle cost analyses that rigorously compare both AC and DC options, considering not only initial capital expenditure but also projected operational costs, energy consumption, maintenance requirements, and potential replacement costs over the building's lifespan.
Demand Energy Efficiency Modeling: Request detailed energy efficiency modeling that quantifies the anticipated energy savings of a DC system compared to a traditional AC system, taking into account the specific building loads and usage patterns.
7. Engage with Industry Resources and Expertise
Leverage the knowledge and experience of others:
Reference Case Studies and Research Findings: Introduce relevant case studies of successful DC building implementations and cite credible research findings to support the discussion and address potential skepticism.
Connect with Industry Associations and Experts: Engage with industry groups, research organizations, and consultants specializing in DC power technologies for buildings. Their expertise and resources can provide valuable insights and guidance.
By proactively employing these multifaceted tactics, building owners and architects can move beyond the status quo and foster a comprehensive evaluation of AC versus DC power systems. This thoughtful and informed approach can pave the way for more efficient, sustainable, and resilient buildings that are well-positioned for the energy landscape of the future.
